Books, India, Movies »
Best Exotic Foolish Things
August 13, 2012 | 2 Comments | Betsy Woodman
I saw a used hard-cover copy of the 2004 novel, These Foolish Things, by British author Deborah Moggach, for sale online for a mere $575.78.
Never heard of that book, you say. Here’s a clue: it’s about British pensioners who land in a retirement home in India and….
Oh, right, right, it was the inspiration for this spring’s hit movie, The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel.
For the 2012 paperback edition of the book, not surprisingly, they changed the title to match the movie, as well as the name of the hotel (originally Dunroamin.) Also, the cover has Dame Judi Densch and Bill Nighy and those other wonderful British actors on it. I read the book this weekend.
Which is better, book or film? As the comedian answered: yes. Both have laugh-out-loud moments, but the book’s comedy is darker, not as feel-good as the movie. The plot’s more complex and cast of characters more numerous, since the pensioners’ children appear, too. You get into the characters’ heads more intimately. Some raunchy British slang and horizontal action give the book an edgier and racier quality than the PG-13 film.
The moviemakers simplified the story and moved the action from Bangalore to the gloriously colorful Rajasthan. They mixed and matched plot elements and characters. Also, they flew the characters over to India as quickly as possible, instead of having them hang around in the U.K.
I loved both book and film. Just to check a few details, I guess I’ll just have to see the movie again.
Betsy — I just finished the book yesterday, too. Your comments are spot on. I loved both. I get irritated sometimes when people complain that a movie was different than the book it was based on; they are two very different art forms and often can both be enjoyed even though different.
Betsy-I just finished JB, which I thoroughly enjoyed. It reminded me a bit of a story of a South African lady detective which HBO made into a series of charming small movies a year or so ago. I could see JB on the small screen-who knows? I agree with Anne about movies and books, although I must say the only boot-to-film translation I thought did justice to the book was Silence of the Lambs, both exceedingly spooky.
BTW, I passed on JB to my wife’s uncle, an old India hand, on the occasion of his 90th birthday. He spent many years in India as an agricultural/banking development guy, and married a Burmese woman while there. I am sure he will find her (JB) as charming as I did.